On Challenging vs Insulting

Jonathan Trenn makes a rather apolitical point that should be at least slightly obvious with regard to the Marcotte Affair ...

OK, I’m a Catholic and I was offended. And I’m no religious fanatic. But the bottom line is this. Organizations - whether they are corporations or presidential campaigns need to be aware that bloggers can be controversial, that bloggers, and that once hired, speak for the organization. And there’s a difference between writing something that ‘challenges us’ and writing someting that insults us.

Adios Amanda.

Categories

1 Comments

Dale said:

For me this raises a larger issue totally unrelated to religion and religious beliefs. This issue relates more to "when is a blog really a blog", and who the hell are these "bloggers" anyway?

By this I mean that a huge percentage of political web sites are not blogs in the original sense of the word, which was short for "web log". Most political advocacy web sites, such as Burnt Orange Report or BlogHouston, are really discussion forums with a point of view. A true web log is a personal journal of activities and events, seasoned by personal insight. However, one cannot make an entire meal from seasoning alone. It seems like most bloggers have no insights to offer, only opinions.

So-called bloggers around the country are pretty full of themselves because of their 15 minutes of fame. Their complete lack of perspective guarantees more and more occurrences like Amanda's, unless "bloggers" moderate themselves substantially. But would there be any point in continuing under those circumstances? Many might say no.

It's not my problem, but I would say that political campaigns will discover quickly how quirky and unreliable this new cohort of political advocates can be. It is not that different from the days I reported city council meetings for an underground newspaper, except that is cheaper and easier than ever to be irresponsible. There are many more Amandas waiting to happen, and religion is not the only territory that will turn into hot lava.

Archives

Subscribe



News Links

Recent Comments

Dale on On Challenging vs Insulting: For me this raises a larger issue totally unrelated to religion and religious beliefs. This issue r

Pages